Dover Street Counter
With a kitchen in full view, a soundtrack worth staying for and some dangerously moreish fries, Dover Street Counter gives a midweek dinner plenty of reasons to run late.
Wednesday can be a tricky night for a restaurant. Sometimes you get a lovely, relaxed evening. Sometimes you get an empty dining room and the uncomfortable feeling that everyone is waiting for you to finish so they can go home.
At Dover Street Counter, nobody appeared to have checked what day it was.
The place was fully booked, the room had a proper buzz and there were seven or eight staff behind the counter, cooking, preparing and sending out plates in front of us. Within minutes, the working week felt considerably less pressing. Faith Evans was on the soundtrack. Dinner could take its time.
Martin Kuczmarski and his team understand how much the setting contributes to an evening. The food matters, of course, but so does that moment when you sit down, look around and think: yes, this was a good idea.
The interiors give you plenty to look at. A stainless-steel counter sits against walnut panelling and glossy black parquet, with low lighting softening the whole thing. There is a late-1950s Los Angeles diner influence, although this is clearly a diner that has done rather well for itself. It looks expensive without making you feel that you ought to sit up straighter.
There are regular tables, and I can see the appeal of settling into one with a group of friends. But if you’re coming for the first time, book the counter. Watching the team work becomes part of the conversation: a plate being finished here, something cooking there, the constant movement of a busy service. You feel involved in the evening rather than simply waiting for dinner to arrive.
Then there is the music. Faith Evans’ Love Like This, TLC, Mase and Destiny’s Child sit comfortably in a run of ’90s favourites. It is the sort of soundtrack that keeps prompting a little flicker of recognition across the counter. Depending on your age, you may spend a fair amount of dinner remembering somewhere you used to dance.
I started with a glass of the house Merlot at £13. Reasonable in this part of Mayfair, particularly in a room where you actually want to linger over it. That sense of proportion carries through the experience. The surroundings have plenty of polish, but the food is approachable and the evening doesn’t need to become an elaborate occasion.
Our tuna tartare coupe, served with avocado and rice crackers, made a very pleasing start. It was an easy dish to settle into while taking in the room, with the crackers giving a little crunch alongside the tuna and avocado.
The disco fries, however, were an immediate distraction.
Covered in mayo, disco jus, pickled chilli and ginger, they were the sort of thing you keep reaching for while insisting you are saving yourself for the next course. We came close to ordering another portion before the mains had even arrived. There is probably a sensible rule about not doubling up on your starter fries. At the time, I struggled to remember it.
Alongside them came a chilled iceberg wedge with candied walnuts and ranch dressing. Iceberg gets a rather unfair reputation as the lettuce with nothing to say, but there is something very appealing about a cold, crunchy wedge among all this richness. It also fitted the mood of the menu: familiar food, given enough attention to make you want it again.
We covered a fair amount of ground with the mains. The Cajun baby chicken came with capers and lemon zest, while beef and fries meant slow-cooked short rib with peppercorn sauce.
The short rib was heavenly. Of everything we ate, this is the dish I would be most reluctant to leave off a return order. There is something deeply satisfying about that combination of slow-cooked beef, peppercorn sauce and fries, especially when the room around you is having as good a time as you are.
The grilled half lobster made a more extravagant addition, served with herb and garlic butter, lemon and chives. Garlic butter has a habit of making an already appealing dish considerably harder to stop eating, and it was doing excellent work here. This was very much an order for pleasure.
Tenderstem broccoli with crushed chilli and ginger vinaigrette joined the spread, along with another side of fries. By this point, our position on potatoes was reasonably clear.
For dessert, we shared New York cheesecake and warm apple and rhubarb pie with cardamom custard and cinnamon sugar. After a meal like this, neither needed to arrive with a lengthy explanation. Cheesecake and warm pie were entirely in keeping with an evening built around things you actually feel like eating. The apple and rhubarb combination, with its custard and spice, felt particularly right for the colder months.
What stayed with me, though, was how easily the whole evening came together. There was plenty happening, but it felt relaxed. The counter gave us something to watch, the music kept the mood up, and the food encouraged the kind of ordering where everyone wants a little of everyone else’s.
I would come back with friends, for drinks and dinner after work, or on a date. Sitting side by side at the counter is particularly good for the latter. There is always something happening in front of you, should either of you briefly run out of intelligent things to say.
Kuczmarski’s restaurants include the more formal glamour of The Dover and Chelsea’s Martino’s. Dover Street Counter offers a more casual way into that world, with handsome surroundings and a menu that lets you decide how far to take the evening. You can have lobster. You can also be extremely happy with fries.
And there is now another address to investigate. Chelsea Counter, newly opened at 39 Cadogan Gardens, brings the counter-dining idea to the neighbourhood just off the King’s Road. Its menu includes comfort-food favourites, slow-cooked short rib and half lobster with herbed garlic butter, alongside a substantial margarita offering. We haven’t eaten there yet, but after our Mayfair visit, it has moved firmly onto the list.
As for Dover Street Counter, I would happily return on another Wednesday. I’d book the counter again, order the short rib and give the second portion of disco fries the consideration it deserved.
Dover Street Counter 31 Dover Street, Mayfair, London, W1S 4ND
Open daily from midday until late. [www.doverstreetcounter.com](https://www.doverstreetcounter.com/)