Amy Matthews
on anger, queerness, heartbreak and the comedy of feeling everything a little bit late.
Comedian Amy Matthews is taking anger, emotional delay, queerness, heartbreak and hotel breakfast appliances and turning them into something unexpectedly funny. Her latest show, Definitions of Toast, begins with a simple problem: Matthews does not really get angry. While everyone else seems permanently furious, her own emotions tend to arrive late, sometimes months after the event that caused them. From there, the show explores everything from relationships and recovery to embracing queerness in her thirties, alongside the kind of wonderfully strange observations that have become a hallmark of her stand-up.
Fresh from Edinburgh, Matthews is now taking Definitions of Toast on an autumn tour across the UK, with dates at multiple venues including Brighton and London.
Ahead of the tour, we spoke to Amy about learning how to be angry, becoming the lead character in her own life, writing honestly about difficult relationships and why putting your rucksack on the seat of a busy train might finally be enough to provoke some rage.
Definitions of Toast starts with the idea that you don’t really get angry, while everyone around you seems increasingly furious. When did you first realise that might actually be something worth building an entire show around?
I think there’s something inherently funny about trying to learn to be angry in a world that is trying to learn not to be. Folk are out there listening to meditation apps on their commute so they don’t wallop someone who is standing a bit too close to them on the Tube, and I’m sat swilling a tea, realising that 18 months ago someone cheating on me was ‘probably not ideal’.
The title has several meanings: something being permanently changed, something being over, and raising a glass to a new beginning. Did the title come first, or did you realise afterwards that ‘toast’ tied all these different parts of the show together?
They fed into each other, I think. It really all tied together when I landed on the analogy of the emotional processing lag I experience being like the toaster in a hotel buffet, in that you put something in, wait for what feels like an eternity, and then it spits something out half-baked. That’s essentially how I experience my emotions. So if my show was about understanding the meaning of my emotional toast, if you will, I looked into the meanings, or rather definitions, of toast. Hence the structure was born!
At the same time, the show deals with previous relationships with people struggling with alcohol. How do you write honestly about something that personal while still deciding what should remain private?
I was extremely mindful of dealing with that as a subject in the most sensitive, nuanced way I could, while also delivering a show with authenticity and rawness. The show itself explores the patterns at play when you find yourself being drawn to relationships or connections with people who are dealing with addiction or alcoholism, despite being lucky enough not to deal with that condition myself. When doing a show like that, it’s so important to keep the focus completely on me, my experience and my story, to make sure I was never speaking on behalf of anyone or disclosing anything that wasn’t mine to share.
It was also important to me that the audience understood that alcoholism and addiction are among the most misunderstood illnesses and conditions, and I hopefully go some way towards raising awareness of that. One of the things I’m most proud of about this show is the number of people who are in recovery or on their sobriety journeys who have said, ‘Thank you for representing that with sensitivity.’ It’s a complex and tricky thing for the person dealing with it and the people around them who love them. This show just gives a mic to the latter.
And what does becoming the lead character look like?
Taking off my glasses and realising I’d been hot this whole time.
You describe your emotions almost as if they arrive with a processing delay. Is comedy sometimes useful because you can finally work out how you felt about something months after it actually happened?
The processing lag that I talk about in the show means that often my default setting is to understand the mechanics of why someone is behaving or emoting in a certain way, why that might be, and how that needs decoding in order for me to understand it. Helpfully, that’s also the process of writing observational stand-up.
Some of the darker themes sit alongside wonderfully odd details, from your mum keeping milk in the boot of her car to a stand-off with a bird and a potion from 2002 that may have cursed the world. Do those strange little observations usually come first, or do you go looking for them once you know what a show is about?
Again, it’s rarely as linear as things coming first or second. I write and edit more holistically than that. When writing a show, particularly one exploring heavier themes, it requires texture, light and shade. The more bizarre, surreal or silly bits are not just there for seasoning. They’re as important as the more analytical, big-theme stuff. You get as much connection out of talking about making potions in your garden as a kid as you do sharing around heartbreak. They’re all part of human experience and all have scope to be as funny and as revealing as each other.
You’ve now had a previous show become an ITVX special, while another was released on vinyl. Does reaching people away from the live room change what success as a stand-up looks like to you?
I think we live in a world of algorithms where everyone is finding their own audience and their own tastes. I think there’s a real freedom in just carving your own path. It made sense to me that a show about using sound as distraction should have a life afterwards as a vinyl or MP3. Similarly, the show before that involved me essentially recreating a living space and had a lot of visual gags in it, hence it was filmed and released as a more conventional special.
I think success in stand-up is being able to deliver work that is aligned with your own creativity and flavour and have that meet audiences at their experiences. That can be a televised special, or a new material night above a pub.
You’ve supported comedians including Ed Byrne, Tom Allen, Sarah Keyworth, Tom Davis and Suzi Ruffell. What have you learnt from watching very different comics deal with very different audiences every night?
I try and take a lesson, nugget or practice from everyone I work with. To use the comics you’ve named as examples, watching Ed’s energy and physicality onstage has categorically helped me find my own. Tom taught me the importance of having a sense of ritual on tour. For instance, he’ll do Fish and Chip Fridays. Tom Davis reminded me that what’s another gig in the diary for us might be the reason an audience member has saved up for a babysitter that night. Keyworth is a masterclass in delivering a polished, watertight show but with space for spontaneity and audience connection. Suzi reminded me to be playful with persona and characterisation onstage.
It’s the beauty of working around so many beautifully talented, delightfully eccentric people all the time. We all get to see each other be at home in our weirdness, and it empowers us all to do our version of the same.
You’re taking Definitions of Toast from Edinburgh into a long autumn tour, including Brighton and London. How much does a show continue changing once you’re on tour, and are there particular audiences or cities where you notice jokes landing completely differently?
It’s really nice that it gets reinvigorated after doing it every day for a month at the Edinburgh Fringe. A new city, a new room, a new audience just totally electrifies it again. As a result, you find yourself ad-libbing a lot more and being more present in the material.
And absolutely, jokes land differently audience to audience. They say insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results, but comedy is doing the same thing over and over and getting different results, which ironically is why we’re all insane.
After spending so much time trying to understand anger for this show, have you actually got any better at being angry, or are you still annoyingly calm?
I still rarely find anger in the moment. That’s part of the processing lag and won’t ever really change, I don’t think. More importantly, I’m better at identifying what will eventually land as anger: injustice, resentment, despair, exhaustion, disappointment. That being said, if you put your rucksack on the seat of a busy train, I think you’ll get a flicker of my version of rage, for sure.
You can catch Amy Matthews at any of her tour dates below. Visit [www.amymatthewscomedy.com/tour](https://www.amymatthewscomedy.com/tour) for more info.