MUTTERING

With a new album on the horizon, Muttering sharpen their sound and embrace raw ambition.

BY MAGGIE DUMONT

Offering an emotive blend of indie, alt-rock & math-rock to the stage, Muttering are getting ready for a big new year.

Since the release of their debut LP, Great, the Brighton & South-London-based quartet have played sold-out shows across Britain, and shared stages with acts like Oversized, Retirement Party, Carly Cosgrove, Michael Cera Palin, and Nervus.

Now they stand at the cusp of releasing an eagerly awaited sophomore album, Love, Keep Me Afraid . And it seems to be a record packed with even more ambition and raw energy. Recorded and produced by guitarist Tom Hill at his studio, The Bookhouse, in South London, it explores intense themes of love, loss and longing.

Ranging from future live favourites and introspective acoustic numbers, this confident collection of songs allows the band’s talents to shine. It’s a complex, multi-instrumental effort which isn’t afraid to progress from spoken word set-pieces to instantly familiar anthems.

As Muttering gets ready for a packed 2026, we spoke to vocalist Charlie Bush to find out more.

How did Muttering come together as a band? What was the initial spark?

Tom and I met around 2017 as he was recording a few projects I was timidly fluffing. Tom runs a recording studio in South Bermondsey, and after a while, he asked me to join him to write an EP together called Don’t Think About It . Charlie (drummer) then joined after the first album, Great .

At the beginning, I wrote lyrics about the end of the world and feeling powerless. I think I tried to get out my frustrations in those songs, and I needed a good outlet to get the fog out of my brain. Tom had various riffs and parts he wanted to use, and we just had a good time together, writing and recording. Once we started playing shows, and we saw Charlie smash his drums (and smile a lot), I think we knew we just wanted to be closer and this is the excuse.

Talk us through the new album. Was there an overriding theme or concept, or is it just a nicely ordered set of songs?

Love, Keep Me Afraid is entirely about relationships and love. The songs were written during the breakdown of my most significant relationship, and I was trying to find ways to understand my role in that breakdown, whilst also feeling upset that I couldn’t fix things. Through those feelings, I was exploring all the important relationships in my life, trying to reason with the pain of love.

As our dearly departed Queen Lizzie said, ‘Grief is the price you pay for love’. When you think about it, all songs are love songs, really, so why not lean into that universal experience? The album moves through the relationship I had with my Dad, my current relationship with my Mum, the loss of a partner, and then onto the building of a new family.

Can you walk us through the typical songwriting process for the band? Is there a specific method you follow, or does it vary depending on the song?

Typically, Tom sends me a video of him playing guitar. He sits, eyes to the camera, drawing me in. I watch that over and over, staring into his blank, expressionless face. I write some lyrics or trawl through my notes app, and then we get in a room and play it all together. I also bring him songs I’ve written, and we workshop those into more guitar-led pieces. Charlie and Tom then wrestle over dynamics and rhythm. I love the writing process with Tom - he’s like a computer, and I’m like his heart. Charlie then makes the songs come together.

What’s your approach to recording? Do you try to get songs down as they’ve been written, or does the experimentation in the studio form an integral part of the process?

It’s all Tom led, we record at his studio, and usually we spend a few days there getting everything together. On this record, Charlie was about to have a baby, so he recorded all the drum parts in one long session, and then we went through the guitars, bass and vocals to finish. To try something different on this record, we brought in a cello player to create atmosphere and build depth on the tracks. We don’t typically experiment much when recording, other than with layering vocal harmonies. The writing process is more creative. In the studio, we try to create an honest representation of what it’ll sound like live.

Your sound seems to coalesce a range of sounds, from American post-punk to C86 indie... Can you identify any definitive influences, or do you just go where the mood takes you?

I’m going to mess this up, because Tom will have a longer list of influences, but it certainly ranges from folk, to Midwest emo to hardcore and 80s pop. Heavier bands like Pianos Become The Teeth and Touche Amore are high up there. I don’t know if that’s reflected throughout the sound of this record, but that’s what we find ourselves listening to a lot and being inspired by.

For me lyrically, I wanted to create something that aligns with 80’s indie like Lloyd Cole, The Smiths or Billy Bragg… maybe 80’s U2. At the time of writing this record, I was listening to a lot of Noah Gunderson, Phoebe Bridgers, Kurt Vile and Big Thief. Again, I’m not sure that’s reflected in the music; I just like that stuff. The aim with this new record was to create a bigger sound whilst exploring more styles and a softer side too. We achieved that.

How would you describe your musical journey from your first release to now?

I think it’s more thoughtful and creative now. I loved our first EP and think it was a turning point for me personally as a writer. However, I think the new record represents us better than ever. I love the time that we spend writing, and I think we have a good understanding of each other now, in terms of our dynamics in the studio. I think that’s where we’re best.

How has Brighton’s music scene and culture influenced your sound and artistic direction?

It’s so varied, and that’s what I love about Brighton. I’ve seen so many different bands, all sorts of age ranges and love that each gig brings me something new to experience, and that breaks me out of my sad music prison. Watching other people do what they love is such a driver for you to get back to writing after a slump, or try something heavier or something prettier. I think it’s the people I’ve met though, that really make the difference. You want to support them just as much as you want to impress them, that’s a nice place to be.

Do you think the city’s nighttime economy is in a good place?

Brighton’s grassroots music scene is so important to me. I see the value it brings to a large community of people. The Hope & Ruin, Green Door Store, Prince Albert, Pipeline, Folklore Rooms, Daltons, Rossi Bar, and all the promoters are such a lynch pin in supporting new bands and creating a flourishing scene.

In London, we’ve met some fantastic people and promoters, but they feel much more up against it. Financially supporting smaller venues is key to building a community. Arts funding is nowhere to be seen, and there needs to be spaces for young people to find their way and meet other creative types to mesh with.

The people we’ve met make me want to keep doing this. In terms of the actual economy, I’m not sure. We’ve got a headline show on Fri 30 Jan at The Hope & Ruin, where we’ve been able to handpick some amazing local support bands, M. Woodroe and ALY… Little things like that feel good and help build a community.

What’s your favourite part about performing live? Do you approach your live performances differently from studio recordings? (Obviously, the former only gives you one chance a night)

I really enjoy writing music. I get very nervous and anxious about performing. However, the actual shows are always a relief by the end of it - a cathartic release of pressure. I love being up there with my friends and knowing we’re all in the same boat. Doesn’t matter what’s been going on at work or at home, for 30 mins you get to be excited about something.

Tom’s amp gets whacked up (arguably too loud), Charlie hits the tubs hard as hell, and I stomp about a bit and belt out the words best I can. We’ve just started playing with our friend Eli on bass and backing vocals, and that gives me more space for singing and a new texture. It’s been a gift to have them along.

A lot of your output seems to explore themes of introspection and emotional depth. Are these based on personal experiences and observations, or are you adept storytellers?

I want to be a great storyteller. I don’t think I’m there yet, but with the new songs, I found a new level I’m pleased with. It’s all meaningful to me, I wouldn’t do the band if I wasn’t allowed to write about myself. Tragic when written down or said aloud, but I need this. It’s like journaling or therapy. There’s a part of me that wants the songs to be heard, so I can feel more seen or understood, but I want it to be relatable to the way others might be feeling. I want connection, and I think that comes from showing parts of yourself.

With the momentum you’ve built so far, what’s next for Muttering? Are there any particular directions or styles you’re eager to explore?

Tom is always scheming away. Before we finished Love, Keep Me Afraid , he already had ideas for the next record and was itching to write. I can’t wait to be part of that. Personally, I want to keep building on the storytelling and understanding the world around me - as well as the people in it. Life can be hard, but there’s always music.